J C Fogarty's: A Cozy American Eatery in Bronxville

I had my baby shower here. The food was very good and the service was great. I was very happy overall. They gave us ample time to set up and break down. I wish there was a switch or an easy way to turn music on or off for speeches/games but if that's the biggest problem, there is none.

We went for my mothers birthday. All I can say is everything was PHENOMENAL! Our server was Mary who couldn't of been better for us from personality to service. She was like having another family member at the table. Luckily, our group ordered a variety of food so we were able to see alot of the items. I had the Lamb Stew which was tender and and packed with flavor. The wings were some of the best I've ever had, the quality of the chicken stood out. Lamb Chops were great, if you go when the have Prime Rib I recommend that too. Eat here, drink here, go here. I want to thank them for making it a memorable experience for my Mom.

The food is a hit and miss. A few times the vegetables were cold. Once the burger was overcooked and dried out. Better atmosphere in the bar. Good for a drink or two or three.

Great Irish pub/restaurant in Bronxville. This is a family owned and operated establishment. The Fogartys are great people who care about the community. Parking is always easy and is directly across the street. The bar area is beautiful with a few booths and great woodwork. There are a few dining areas with rooms that can accommodate any size party. The upstairs bar are and rooftop are amazing and provide a great experience. The staff is always friendly and professional and the food is fantastic from the appetizers to the entrees. Mr. Fogarty is always there greeting the customers and making sure everything runs smooth. The bar hosts multiple community events during the year and they are always willing to give back ! If you are looking to have a drink or a romantic night out make it Fogartys.

If I could give 10 stars I would. Free parking across the street, a working gas fireplace when you walk in the door, very pristine and spacious and not stuffy. Fish & chips were probably the best I ever had and the waiter was super attentive. Real Irish music playing in the background as well.

The food and service were excellent. Ordered Prime Rib and it was tender and delicious. Definitely will be going back.

We went for Mother’s Day dinner. Luckily, parking wasn’t hard at dinnertime on a Sunday (I was surprised, normally the lot is terrible in Bronxville) Dinner was good and most importantly, my mom was happy lol. Pictured: Fried stuffed mushroom app, sole & crabmeat entree and apple pie.

Great local pub to grab a drink, busy during the holidays and some weekends. Check the schedule, sometimes a live band. Food is good but little too expensive for what it is. grab a drink, skip the meal